UK Retailer files low carb health claim

UK retailer Marks & Spencer has filed a claim with the European regulator EFSA for their "Balanced for You" range of ready meals with a limited ratio of carbohydrate to protein.

Chef succeeds on Atkins Diet

Another personal testimony from the Atkins UK forum :-

Hi Folks,

A have been following some of the threads on this forum for a couple of months now but have not posted until now, so this is my first post here. 

Atkins Diet success story

Shirley, age 63 and with hypothyroidism, reports a weight loss of 6 stone / 84 lbs / 38 kg in 17 months through following the Atkins diet without exercise and with support from the Atkins UK community forum. That's an average loss of over 1.2 lbs per week.

Here's her story in her own words......

Fat Fast / Cream Day

Well here I am 3 years down the line, and still eating low carb. My current weight is 11 stone 10 lbs ( 164 lbs or 74.5 kg if you prefer other units ) which is as low as I've ever measured. I must have weighed this as a boy, but boys don't weigh themselves. My BMI is 23 !! Low carb delivers, and I haven't "put it all back on again" as various cynics, refuseniks, dietitians and general tossers on the internet would have you believe.

I dropped 8 lbs recently on a rather good and special holiday, more of which later.

About a month ago I did a sort of "fat fast" to try to boost my weight loss a bit and see if I could increase the ketone levels in my blood - aiming for the "nutritional ketosis" nirvana that people enthuse about on the web. I wrote it up as a document that you can read or download from Google Drive

Dr Atkins described a fat fast in his original book in 1972, used to kick start his diet in some resistant individuals who needed to have very low levels of carbohydrate and protein to cut down their blood sugar levels and get the brain switching over to use ketones from fat as its primary fuel. From memory he aimed at 1000 calories with basically all of them (90%) from fat - macadamia nuts and some cream cheese for example. A fat fast cookbook has been published recently, for those looking for detailed guidance, but I haven't read it yet.

My fat fast delivered a 3 pound weight loss in one day, and ketone levels increased progressively with the overnight fasted result up in the magic "nutritional ketosis" range :-

I think a fair chunk of the weight loss was water associated with glycogen, as the lack of carb intake and the day's activities would have depleted my liver's glycogen reserves and forced the use of glucose and ketones produced by the liver to provide the body's energy requirements (along with fatty acids from my fat stores, of course).

My total food intake for the day was 1480 calories, with 78% from fat and 71 grams of protein, so this was not a real "hard core" fat fast to the letter, but a decent amount of food with controlled protein, low carbohydrate and lots of lovely nutritious fats to scare the cardiologists away.

It's interesting that 40+ years after Atkins wrote his book "Dr. Atkins' Diet Revolution" , and 10 years after his death, people like me can re-discover his ideas and find they are still relevant. They may in fact still be "best practice"  despite all the low fat calorie restriction dogma we have been subjected to since.

Nutritional Guidelines & low carb eating

Let's take a look at UK nutritional guidelines, from the back of a pack of ASDA Mackerel fillets :-

Guideline daily amounts
                          Women                  Men
Calories                   2000                 2500
Protein                     45g                  55g
Carbohydrate               230g                 300g
of which sugars             90g                 120g
Fat                         70g                  95g
of which saturates          20g                  30g
Fibre                       24g                  24g


In the early stages of my low carb diet I was limiting my carbohydrate intake to below 20g per day. This means I was eating 280g less than the guidelines, a saving of 1120 calories per day ! That is enough to drop my calories to 1380 per day if nothing else changes.


1120 calories per day is equivalent to about 124g of fat from my ample deposits, so a loss rate of 124g per day relative to the standard guidelines looked to be on offer. At 871g per week that's 1.9 pounds (lbs) per week and close to 50 lbs or 3.5 stones in 6 months. Perhaps a bit more if you include the water weight that is also stored with the fat on your body.


I did actually lose 3 stones in 6 months, from just over 16 stone in April 2010 to just under 13 stone in October 2010. So the reduction in carbohydrate compared to the standard food guidelines seems to equate to my weight loss, more or less.


In practice I eat more protein than the guidelines, probably 90-100g say 50g more which is 200 calories more. My fat intake is probably around the 95g mark, so my calories are approximately  :-


Carbohydrates   20g    80 calories
Protein        100g   400 calories
Fat             95g   855 calories


Total                1335 calories, 64% of which from fat.


Am I losing out by having a low carbohydrate intake ? Not in my opinion. There are essential minerals and vitamins we have to eat, and essential fatty acids. "Essential" means we have to have it and we can't make our own, so we have to eat it. There are no essential carbohydrates !


Low carb dieters adapt to use fat as a muscle and brain fuel, to replace the glucose that would otherwise be used. The whole blood stream only contains about 5g of glucose so it is continually being used and replaced with glucose from food or from previously stored glycogen. When the supply of glucose isn't enough then fat is broken down and ends up as ketones to fuel muscles and the brain. Some parts of the body can only use glucose, but there's enough for them from conversion of protein ie Gluconeogenesis.


Once adapted to low carb eating my blood sugar became stable, I didn't feel hungry and sugar highs and lows were a thing of the past. My metabolism has adapted to my diet which is no longer based around fast absorbed carbohydrates as recommended in the Guideline Daily Amounts.